18
Oct
2023
Watch
The despicable terrorist attacks by Hamas against Israel, Israel’s right to defend itself in line with humanitarian and international law and the humanitarian situation in Gaza (debate)
Madam President, Hamas' barbarism has shocked us deeply. No cause – I insist, no cause – justifies the killing of innocent people. We feel the immense pain of the people of Israel. We also feel the terrible suffering expressed by the relatives of the hostages, who today accompany us in the Chamber. Shira, Jonathan, Noam, we will not rest until your families return home. We will have no better way to help Israel than our commitment not to give in to the quest for peace, a peace that must prevent us from witnessing again last night's massacre at Al Alhi Hospital, with more than 500 sick people, children and elderly Palestinians killed. Mrs von der Leyen, besides showing our Union's solidarity with the Israeli people, which of course we have to do - and you did - did you remind Mr Netanyahu that crimes are never fought with other crimes? Did Mr. Netanyahu rebuke his defense minister's unworthy language after calling Gazans human animals? Did you tell Mr Netanyahu that your ultimatum for one million Gazans to leave their homes in a few hours in a situation of helplessness was totally unacceptable? In short, did it remind you that there will only be lasting peace when the Palestinians see their future with hope? Ladies and gentlemen, at a time when the lives of millions of human beings are in danger, the European Union cannot make any more mistakes, intolerable mistakes such as the attempt - proposed by Commissioner Várhelyi - to suspend all aid to Palestine. We now have an obligation to lead an international mediation to achieve a ceasefire, release Israeli and European hostages, save the wounded Palestinians crammed into hospitals and open a humanitarian corridor in Egypt. This is not the time for ideological battles or double standards. Israel has every right to fight Hamas and respond to the heinous attack on October 7, but it is obliged to respect international law. The killing of civilians in Gaza, the siege of water, food, electricity, medicines and the intolerable ultimatum of population displacement are in violation of international humanitarian law. Ladies and gentlemen, after the persecution of the Jewish people for centuries and the extermination of six million Jews by Nazi cruelty, the Jewish people achieved their dream: a state of its own. It has also long been the right of the Palestinian people to achieve their own dream: the right to one's own State, to a Palestinian State that can live in peace with the State of Israel. Because peace is always possible. And if peace was possible after millennia of wars here on our land, on the land we now tread, it can and must also be possible in the land of the Middle East. The European Union's responsibility as a peace-exporting power is to act together to contribute to a peaceful and just solution, however impossible it may seem; a solution to build a free and hate-free Middle East; a Middle East where walls will fall forever and weapons will be shut down forever; a Middle East of open roads, schools, hospitals, decent housing. In short, a Middle East that in the end we can call home. Now that thirty years have passed since the Oslo Accords were signed, we must remember that the only possible path to peace was taught to us by Labour Prime Minister Isaac Rabin. He sacrificed his life for peace and today his words must guide us to move forward in the peace process as if there were no terrorism and to fight terrorism as if there were no peace talks.