State sponsored terrorism by the Islamic Republic of Iran in light of the recent attacks in Europe (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, we are extremely concerned about the explosions and shootings that took place near the Israeli embassies in Stockholm and Copenhagen. We are waiting for the investigation to continue but the hypotheses seem to lead right to the track of Iranian state-sponsored terrorism. In the face of these serious events, we cannot remain helpless: We must be inflexible as Europeans. This Parliament has long denounced the Iranian regime, its infiltrations, its activities to suppress human rights and the democratic aspirations of its own people. In 2023, Iranian women received the Sakharov Prize for Freedom of Thought. Today we are still calling for respect for human rights in Iran and we have called for the inclusion of the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps on the list of terrorist organizations. Europe must not allow itself to be exploited, but must remain vigilant and not ignore the cry for help of the Iranian people and denounce any attempt to interfere and, of course, to support terrorism.
Establishing the Ukraine Loan Cooperation Mechanism and providing exceptional macro-financial assistance to Ukraine (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, the European Parliament is called upon to concretely renew solidarity with Ukraine with the new loan cooperation mechanism, which I am proud to have worked on behalf of my political group. An urgent and necessary tool to support a European country that is under the brutal and unjustified attack of Putin's Russia, which is intensifying its war effort precisely to destroy Ukraine's strategic and energy infrastructure, right now that winter is approaching to cause further suffering to a people fighting for its freedom. A right instrument, because the 45 billion of aid that will arrive in Kiev will be financed by the profits deriving from the asset frozen Russian sovereigns, because the cost of supporting Ukraine must be paid by those responsible for such devastation, not by European citizens. I believe that the Union must therefore keep all options open to ensure effective support for financial stability and the reconstruction of Ukraine, because Europe's future passes through here.
Protecting the EU budget and ensuring that EU funds do not benefit entities or individuals linked to terrorist or Islamist movement (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, the sole purpose of this right-wing debate is to slander UNRWA, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees. Thanks to EU funds, it provides schools, primary health centres and other essential services to millions of people, children, women and men. This debate is superfluous because the European Commission, less than a year ago, has already verified the financial assistance to Palestine, decreeing the legality, neutrality and independence of UNRWA. More: The Agency was also subject to an independent review, the Colonna report, which confirmed its full neutrality. As High Representative Borrell has already said, in the absence of evidence, the right accuses without foundation and I also say this to those of the Italian right who have uttered calumnies in this House. There are no Hamas supporters here. UNRWA must be funded and supported because it is a vital lifeline for millions of refugees in Gaza and beyond. Let us not allow the civilian population, already massacred by war, to suffer collective punishment. Stop the massacres, stop the cruelty, support the people, thanks to those who, like the UNRWA organization has always done, will continue to do it, must be able to continue to do it, if we still preserve a bit of humanity.
Outcome of the Summit of the Future: transforming global governance for building peace, promoting human rights and achieving the sustainable development goals (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, the 'Pact of the future of the United Nations' must be supported because it promotes a more interconnected multilateralism in order to tackle today's challenges together. It is a right choice and one of these challenges is undoubtedly the functioning of international institutions. True, we need a more effective, representative and financially stable UN system. Without deep reform, there is a risk of irrelevance and irreparable loss of credibility. We also see this in the current crises, what is happening around us. And then the Global Digital Compact, It calls for global digital cooperation through more responsibilities for technology companies, online platforms and a roadmap for global governance of artificial intelligence. We as the European Union can only support this approach in line with what we have already done on the subject. I worked as a speaker of theAI Act I think we need to continue to play a leading role. Now is the time of truth. States must respect their commitments and responsibilities in the face of the new generations, those who will live the future more than any of them.
Organised crime, a major threat to the internal security of the European Union and European citizens (topical debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, Europol's recent report on the 821 most dangerous criminal networks operating within the European Union paints an alarming, but not surprising, picture. The mafias today are increasingly agile, more transnational, active in a multiplicity of sectors. Links with their countries of origin are weakened. Today, the money accumulated through illicit activities is transferred and laundered to distant places, often without leaving traces, thanks to new technologies such as cryptocurrencies and also the use of the dark web. The phenomenon, therefore, cannot be managed exclusively at national level: calls for increasingly effective and rapid forms of investigative and judicial cooperation at European level. An important role must be played by the European Public Prosecutor’s Office, as an independent body from the EU and the Member States, with an initiative in investigating and prosecuting cases, but also by Europol and Eurojust. New and appropriate tools are needed. It is also essential in this European Parliament to reconstitute a parliamentary committee against the mafia and organised crime, because this is not a cost: It is a necessary investment for security, legality and democracy.
Outcome of G20 ministerial meeting in Rio-de-Janeiro and fighting inequality (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, the work being carried out by the Brazilian presidency of the G20 deserves not only our applause, but also our full support. President Lula's push to tackle global inequalities is now at the heart of the G20 agenda, and what was adopted at the last ministerial meeting in Rio is a big step forward in tackling world hunger, poverty and climate change. The Rio Declaration does not escape what I believe to be the key theme: building a direct link between fiscal justice and economic and social justice. For the first time in history, all G20 member countries recognize the need to address the system of taxation of the super-rich on our planet, committing to work on a common solution. Without fiscal justice there is no democracy, because without the distribution of wealth, governments cannot offer essential services, from education to health, social and social security issues, to environmental protection. We need a global taxation of at least 2% on billionaire assets, otherwise the range of inequalities is destined to widen more and more, to the point of no return. That is why we must also support the European Citizens' Initiative, which goes in this direction.
War in the Gaza Strip and the situation in the Middle-East (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, an average of five children have been killed or injured every day since October 2023. I'm not talking about Gaza, I'm talking about the West Bank. These numbers speak for themselves. Netanyahu's government's intentions are clear: violate the right of the Palestinian people to have their own state and prevent peaceful coexistence between Israelis and Palestinians, continuing the ongoing massacre in Gaza for the survival of its government. It is time for Netanyahu to leave and it is crucial that those ministers who defend settler violence are sanctioned directly by the European Union. We can't have double standards. Europe must do its part. We need an immediate ceasefire - we say it - the release of all hostages and a two-state political solution with the involvement of the international community. We need to recognize the State of Palestine. From here, too, I urge the Italian Government to follow the example of Norway, Spain and Ireland. It is time to build peace together.
Global measures towards social media platforms - Strengthening the role of DSA and protecting democracy and freedom in the online sphere (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, the Digital Services Act finally empowers and protects European citizens from disinformation and fake news, placing limits on the action of platforms. The European Commission has done an important job, but there is still a lot to be done. But if Trump isn't happy, I think we're on the right track. And the Member States, the guarantors of privacy, are also moving in the same direction. I am referring, for example, to the absolute prohibition of advertising targeted at minors. But we need to go further. For example, thanks to the European regulation on artificial intelligence, we have added among the high-risk systems, and therefore more regulated, those that operate in the context of democratic processes. We have also introduced the obligation to clearly label content generated by artificial intelligence to combat the abuse of deep fakes. Protecting our democracy from disinformation is protecting our future. It's true in Europe, but it's also true globally.
Need to prevent security threats like the Solingen attack through addressing illegal migration and effective return (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, my commitment as a Member of the European Parliament began in this House ten years ago. Many things have changed since then, and I have changed too, but my will to fight for a fairer Europe, capable of responding to people's needs, of overcoming fears by finding the solutions we need together, has never changed. For this reason, on a story like this in Solingen, the answer cannot be to lock ourselves up in a propaganda fort, but to address the issues for what they are. We need to make sure that our citizens can feel safe and that crimes are prosecuted and prevented. However, we must prevent individual episodes from turning into a collective psychosis; rather, action must be taken on many different fronts – integration, cultural dialogue, the management of people’s movements, the repression of crime, cyber security. We cannot give up our liberties for supposed security, because then we will no longer be free or secure. Instead, we must work for our democracy to stop violence and hatred. It is a great, fundamental commitment to which we too are called as representatives of Europeans.
EU-Egypt strategic and comprehensive partnership and agreements with key third countries (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, EUR 7 400 million. This is the value of the agreement between the European Union and Egypt, signed in March at the court of al-Sisi with Giorgia Meloni in the company of Ursula Von der Leyen. There will be as many as 200 million used to stop the departures of migrants, still outsourcing the control of European borders and ignoring human rights. This agreement was not only signed bypassing the scrutiny of the European Parliament, but completely ignores the serious rule of law situation in Egypt. Indeed, cooperation with this country cannot ignore our demand to respect human rights by guaranteeing freedom of expression, releasing arbitrarily detained persons and ending the repression of minorities. The presence of Patrick Zaki, detained for months by the Egyptian regime and now finally free, reminded us in these days, here in the European Parliament, that he told us "if I am here it is because you too in these classrooms believed that fighting for my freedom was a battle to be won". We are also asked by the parents of Giulio Regeni, who died more than eight years ago in Egypt and for whom we are still looking for the truth. A truth that the Egyptian authorities continue to cover up and that the Italian government and the European authorities should demand much more forcefully. Yes, fighting for freedom and for truth is a battle to be won. And as Europe, we will have to continue to do so. Certainly the European Parliament will have to prevent this kind of commitment from being blocked by agreements without monitoring, without transparency, carried out by governments in an absolutely unacceptable way.
EU’s response to the repeated killing of humanitarian aid workers, journalists and civilians by the Israel Defence Forces in the Gaza Strip (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, more than 34,000 dead and more than 77,000 injured: And it is only a partial budget, the last one, after hundreds of days of war in Gaza and the massacre continues. Seven aid workers from the NGO World Central Kitchen were recently killed by the Israeli army. It must be said clearly: It is a war crime that we condemn and for which a thorough investigation will be needed to punish the perpetrators. There are also numerous victims among the operators of the UN agency that deals with Palestinian refugees, accused by Netanyahu's government of having participated in the attack on October 7. There is no evidence to support the allegations: A recent independent analysis by former French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna clearly states that the Agency is irreplaceable and indispensable. But we know it, we have also said it in this Parliament. Europe needs to act now to prevent an escalation and to achieve an immediate ceasefire and the unconditional release of all hostages still in the hands of Hamas. We work for an international peace conference and a UN mission in Gaza. We are working to stop the massacre.
(IT) Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, I just wanted to point out to the whole House that we have here with us today, in the balcony following this moment of voting, Patrick Zaki, a human rights activist imprisoned in Egypt for many years who, thanks also to our commitment here in the Chamber, the resolutions, the commitment that we have carried out - it was carried out first of all by President Sassoli during his presidency - today he can be here with us. He is free and no longer in Egyptian prisons. I think it is important to bring back to you what he told me yesterday when he arrived here that the fact that he is here and is no longer in prison is a demonstration that the struggles for human rights, for the activists, that we carry out in this House, can sometimes seem like desperate undertakings, but instead sometimes they lead to results, to free people who are in prison only for the desire to express their ideas and to be free people. So it is also the symbol of a struggle for human rights that we carry out and that we must continue to carry out together. Thanks to Patrick, thanks for being here.
Common rules promoting the repair of goods (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, many billions of euros are currently lost a year in the purchase of new goods to replace broken ones, when it would be possible to repair them, not counting the 35 million tonnes of waste generated, because it is easier to throw away the broken phone or computer and buy a new one instead of repairing it. Europe often seems distant from the citizens, but the right to reparation that our political group has been asking for for years – we have fought a lot, here there are those who have dealt with it most of all, René Repasi, whom I thank for having carried out this battle for all of us – represents a real turning point for consumers, as well as for the planet. Finally, manufacturers will have to make it possible to access spare parts and the possibility of repairing products at reasonable prices and with an extension of the warranty. With these new measures, repair will be incentivised in the Member States and will allow consumers to save a lot, freeing up valuable resources in these difficult times and also safeguarding the environment from new waste and the overproduction of goods. It is a real turning point in the lives of all of us and I think Europe is moving forward even with these small steps that change people's lives piece by piece.
Promised revision of the EU animal welfare legislation and the animal welfare-related European citizens’ initiatives (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, European citizens care about animal welfare and the Eurobarometer data speak volumes. Citizens are calling on the European Union to better protect the welfare of farmed animals: a limitation of the duration of the transport of animals and also a greater protection of the welfare of pet animals. However, there are too many economic interests that prevail over the work carried out by the European Parliament, which has repeatedly called for the revision of existing rules that are obsolete, limited and often inapplicable. The European Commission's backlash against the ban on the use of cages on farms is a slap in the face to the commitment of the many who have spent their time in the "End the Cage Age" campaign, a European citizens' initiative signed by 1.4 million people. That's enough now. We ask for a clear plan, with precise timeframes; of the promised reforms, namely four proposals, only a weak proposal for a regulation on the transport of animals has been tabled. I am convinced that after the next European elections we will have to set up a European Commissioner for Animal Welfare; The citizens are asking us to do this and it is a first step that is not only symbolic, it is a necessary step forward.
Rising anti-LGBTIQ rhetoric and violence: recent attacks in Thessaloniki (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, unfortunately, even in this House, in the celebration of the International Day for Women's Rights, we have heard transphobic words so it is a problem that everywhere, here too, is a cultural problem, a problem of laws. It applies to Thessaloniki, it applies to Greece, to the acts of violence that we remember, but it also applies to my country, Italy, where there continue to be suicides of girls and boys of the LGBTQIA+ community. There is violence, there is bullying, there is discrimination at all levels. We need to give a clear sign, a cultural, political and law change. Europe must ensure that all Member States put in place clear anti-discrimination laws and that criminals committing homophobic and transphobic attacks are always properly prosecuted. We must work together, it cannot be a theme that divides, we must be united because every life is worth it.
The immediate risk of mass starvation in Gaza and the attacks on humanitarian aid deliveries
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, the famine in Gaza is much more than a risk, it is the dramatic reality that children, women and men are living in these hours, victims of the strategy of the Netanyahu government. High Representative Borrell also said: The humanitarian crisis in Gaza is not a natural disaster, Israel is using hunger as a weapon of war. What is happening at the Rafah crossing is inhumane and was observed on the spot by a delegation of parliamentarians from various political forces, starting with the Italian Democratic Party: Water, food, medicines, generators for hospitals cannot cross the border. That is why I myself, together with some of my fellow Members, have tabled a parliamentary question to the European Commission to commit to and to unblock this humanitarian aid financed by European funds that are still at the gate. But Europe needs to raise its voice now: Stop starvation as a weapon of war! An immediate ceasefire is needed to negotiate the release of human beings hostage to Hamas terrorists, and I believe it is time for the Netanyahu government to go home, for Netanyahu to resign and leave room for a new season that can build peace.
This is Europe - Debate with the Prime Minister of Finland, Petteri Orpo (debate)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, Mr Orpo, the idea of Europe that your government represents is the opposite of what is needed: an alliance where self-styled moderate and pro-European parties bow to the nationalist and reactionary right like the True Finns party. A model that perhaps can please the Melons and Salvini of Europe, but that produces only division, weakness, isolation and fragility for Europe. Let's not forget the demented, racist, homophobic statements of the multi-condemned President of the Finnish Parliament, not to mention the story of the former Minister of Economy who had to resign for pro-Nazi comments. Not only claims, but also destructive reforms such as your changes to the labor market and social security, which have led workers to protest in the streets for days. We are against these piles where self-styled pro-Europeans wink at the far right; It is true in Italy and it is true in Europe, where at the next elections we will have to work to keep Europe on a clear path. President Orpo, do not let the real Finns dictate the agenda, show, in the interests of Finns and Europeans, that you are a real European.
(IT) Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, I would again like to thank Mr Tudorache for the work he has done together, the fellow rapporteurs of the political groups, but also you, Commissioner Breton, for the work carried out even in the difficult negotiations that you have mentioned, I am thinking about fundamental issues such as the safety of the most powerful models, an issue on which we have taken stock of the need to give answers on this to our citizens, but also to our European businesses. It is very important now to work on implementation, as has been said by many and many, but it will also be important that Europe in the coming years equips itself with the necessary tools to be competitive, based on our vision of the future of artificial intelligence. It means completing the capital markets union, it means working on common investments and research, on sharing the computational capabilities of our supercomputers. Member States also need to play their part. I also think of my country, the Meloni government, which has announced many laws and committees on several occasions, but which still does not allocate resources for the development of artificial intelligence. This also applies to other countries, of course. We need a strong stimulus because we have before us a great challenge, to make Europe really lead the development of artificial intelligence, which cannot be achieved only by regulation, we need many other measures. We will all work on it in the next stages, but we have seen with this work, with this commitment, that when Europe really is united, really works together and makes the best use of the strength of its single market and its integrated market, it is able to give a clear line and really achieve a change that is needed.
Mr President, Commissioner Breton, ladies and gentlemen, after two intense years of work, we have finally come to pass the world's first binding law on artificial intelligence, aimed at reducing risks and increasing opportunities, combating discrimination, giving transparency, bringing our democratic values of freedom and equality into the development of these new technologies, while supporting innovation and competitiveness. Thanks to us, in the European Parliament, after a hard negotiation, unacceptable practices in Europe will be banned already by the end of the year, such as the recognition of emotions in the workplace and in the places of study, such as inferring a person's ethnic, religious or political affiliation on the basis of biometric data. An algorithm cannot predict whether a specific person will commit a crime by violating the presumption of innocence. workers must always be informed and trade unions involved in the use of artificial intelligence in the workplace. In short, we fight discrimination, we protect the rights of citizens and workers. These are some important examples of what we have achieved. In the final text we confirmed the plan of risk reduction for all the most sensitive areas, such as the use of AI in the medical field, in the administration of justice, in the workplace, in democratic procedures, thanks to the verification of compliance on data quality and appropriateness, cybersecurity, human control. Let's say that's enough of an artificial intelligence that systematically discriminates against women or non-white people when it has to select resumes or exposes patients to risks on the management of their health data. These are cases that we know and that we want to contrast with a rule that is finally able to act on this front. We want to increase the conscious use of artificial intelligence systems, not disincentivize it. People will know that thanks to these rules they will be able to use the systems with the greatest possible protection. But thanks to the work of the European Parliament, we have also achieved a lot in terms of transparency: Enough of the indiscriminate use of deep fake that will be made recognizable directly by the devices through the so-called "watermarking", an invisible labeling, and let's say enough to the use of copyrighted content without protection for their holders, because the right to be recognized the economic value of creativity and what is achieved by people is a right that must also be protected within the context of the development of artificial intelligence. We still have a lot to do. For the start of this implementation work is being built theAI Office, the European Artificial Intelligence Office, and we will have to accompany institutions and businesses in voluntary early compliance, in supporting the application of the rules before they are fully mandatory; a gradual accompaniment path that will also focus, for example, on the development of what we wanted, as a Parliament, namely the verification of fundamental rights, the impact assessment – something that will be crucial for the users of artificial intelligence to also play their part in reducing risks. I want to thank for this great work, which puts Europe at the forefront and which charts a path that we will have to continue with the planned directives, for example on artificial intelligence in the world of work, I want to thank my fellow rapporteurs, my fellow rapporteur Mr Tudorache and colleagues from the other political groups for this. We have achieved a lot because Parliament, Parliament's team, has been able to be united in negotiating according to our vision, that of truly putting the human being and European values at the heart of the development of artificial intelligence.
Horizontal cybersecurity requirements for products with digital elements and amending Regulation (EU) 2019/1020 (A9-0253/2023 - Nicola Danti) (vote)
Madam President, ladies and gentlemen, I just want everyone, including those who listen to us and those who follow us, to know that Mr Ciocca is not new to doing these scenes. Even now, while we were voting, while we are doing our duty for the citizens of Europe, he does scenes only to be sent perhaps on social media or in some communication tool. It makes us ridiculous, it humiliates our work and I think it's a shame that these things can happen without immediate action. We need more readiness because we make ourselves ridiculous in front of the European citizens. Ours is serious work, you cannot do these scenes in this House because there are those who do nothing, do only this, do not work in Parliament, do not make amendments, do not produce anything and make the citizens believe that our work is this.
Council and Commission statements - Preparation of the European Council meeting of 21 and 22 March 2024 (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, we are not convinced by President von der Leyen's words here this morning. While around us Viktor Orbán hopes for Trump's return and Netanyahu says there will never be a Palestinian state, Europe must decide whether to disappear or become big, it cannot be content with half-way choices. We have heard of a humanitarian aid ship in Gaza, the first in many years, including the resumption of the enlargement process. Well, that's not enough! Europe cannot defend international law every other day, Gaza needs an immediate ceasefire and, in order for Europe to really accept new Member States and not delude them, it needs to proceed with reforms. Today we have too many vetoes and we risk going back on the choice of common debt, while we need a shared budget and taxation, even starting from those who, among the member countries, are ready to take these steps. Faced with what is happening in the world, a Europe of "too late, too little" will be wiped out. I therefore ask the Commission and the leaders of the European Council to live up to the moment we are living in.
Madam President, Commissioner Breton, ladies and gentlemen, this regulation finally creates a true European digital identity. I have followed this dossier thanks to my role as negotiator for the Socialists and Democrats in the opinion of the Committee on Legal Affairs and Citizens' Rights, and allow me to congratulate the rapporteur-general, Romana Jerkovic, on her excellent work. The new European Digital Identity Wallet will respect data protection and privacy. open source, on a voluntary basis and will allow storing personal data, credentials and attributes for easy access to services in all Member States. All this, without having to pay a commercial supplier: For example, citizens will be guaranteed the use of free electronic signatures. After the Artificial Intelligence Act, Europe must also be a world leader in the field of digital identity, putting people and their rights at the centre. From today we are European citizens not only offline but also online.
Data collection and sharing relating to short-term accommodation rental services (debate)
Madam President, Commissioner Breton, ladies and gentlemen, the regulation on the collection and sharing of data on short-term accommodation rental services is an important new piece of the European mosaic. I am happy to have followed him as a negotiator for the Socialists and Democrats Group. Let me also immediately thank the rapporteur, Kim Van Sparrentak, for the extraordinary work she has done in recent months. Online short-term rental platforms have stimulated the tourism economy but have also led to the so-called gentrification tourism of cities, undermining their livability and accessibility of housing. We cannot forget the university students who a few months ago in my country, in Italy, slept in tents in the squares, demonstrating against the dear rents for the off-site. And this problem also affects workers and families struggling with an out-of-control housing market. Today, some platforms do not comply with existing obligations and states are moving in order. The legislative vacuum in the area of short-term rentals is a real problem. This Regulation harmonises registration procedures between Member States. host, online platforms and competent authorities: This is not the final solution, but it is certainly a key first step in giving Member States the tools they need to legislate properly. I am proud that all our priorities have been confirmed. The host They will receive a registration number. Online platforms will need to ensure that the information provided by host they are correct and, finally, the authorities will be able to act in the event of fraudulent use of the activities of the platforms. In short, transparency and rules to ensure that, finally, political choices can be made in an ever-growing sector, that of short rents. The Europe we want, capable of imposing useful and effective rules even on those with great power such as digital platforms, is built step by step with choices like this.
Madam President, I would like to raise an item on the agenda, pursuant to Rule 195 of Parliament's Rules of Procedure. We have heard the heartbreaking testimony of Yulia Navalnaya, a reminder of the need to step up our efforts to protect those who, like Navalny, have made the defence of human rights and dignity their mission. Together with other colleagues and Gariwo – the gardens of the Righteous, I sent you a letter asking you to commit the European Parliament to solemnly celebrate the European Day of the Righteous on 6 March. The day would be made particularly significant by the launch of an appeal for the release of Yuri Dmitriev and Narges Mohammadi, true fighters for truth and justice, still imprisoned by the regimes of Moscow and Tehran. An appeal for their release must become a shared political objective: We hope that you can accept our request and give substance to the European Day of the Righteous on 6 March.
Human rights and democracy in the world and the European Union’s policy on the matter – annual report 2023 (debate)
Mr President, ladies and gentlemen, 11 days ago was the terrible but predictable news of the murder of Alexei Navalny, yet another crime on Putin’s conscience: This is a very serious crime that the entire international community must firmly condemn. We can't help but talk about the state of human rights in the world. As a Union, we cannot allow other cases like this to happen. For this reason, on March 6, the European Day of the Righteous, established also thanks to the commitment of the Gariwo association, committed to the Gardens of the Righteous, we will ask even more forcefully for the release of Yuri Dmitriev and Narges Mohammadi, true fighters for freedom, justice and truth, still imprisoned by the Russian and Iranian regimes. Europe must lead by example: David Sassoli said in 2019 that we were not an accident of history. Well, today I allow myself to borrow those words. Navalny's death cannot and must not be an accident in history, but it must be a force for our support for those who fight against violations of human rights and freedoms everywhere in the world.