Vote in the European Parliament

2023 discharge: General budget of the EU - Commission

Niclas Herbst – After § 1 – Am 55
Date: 07.05.2025·Reference: A10-0074/2025
Rapporteur: Niclas Herbst

Overall Result

Rejected
  • 169 For
  • 429 Against
  • 41 Abstention
  • 80 Did not vote
Amendment— You are viewing a sub-vote (amendment) of the main vote.Amendment 55 · Motion for a resolution · Tabled by PfEView amendment at the EP ↗
Amendment wording

Tabled by Virginie Joron, Julien Sanchez, Nikola Bartůšek, Anders Vistisen

Added: 1 b. Deplores the scandal of the purchase of 4.6 billion doses of Covid vaccine for 71 billion euros by the President of the Commission and the recent purchase of a further 146 million doses for an unknown amount ; Whereas the European Commissioner for Health testified on 27/03/2023 before the COVI Special Committee that President Von der Leyen was not involved in any COVID vaccine contract negotiations, contrary to the information published by the New York Times (28/04/2021) and the conclusions of the European Court of Auditors in its special report on the purchase of COVID-19 vaccines; whereas the Commission has required certain Members of Parliament on the COVI Committee to sign a confidentiality undertaking on May 30, 2023, without specifying an end date for this confidentiality obligation concerning an indemnity paid per dose by Europeans to Pfizer in exchange for the non-delivery of certain doses still to be delivered ; expresses its disappointment at the Commission's persistent lack of transparency regarding the agreements it has concluded with the pharmaceutical companies responsible for producing COVID-19 vaccines, as well as the SMS communications between the Commission President and the CEO of a pharmaceutical company, to the extent that legal action has tarnished the Commission's reputation when the President could easily have explained herself to Parliament; deplores the Commission's inaction in relation to the serious side-effect victims of COVID vaccines in terms of medical research and compensation; deplores the fact that the Commission has chosen to defend Pfizer rather than the Member States in the legal dispute between them over the refusal to order doses of vaccine no longer needed after the end of the pandemic; notes the extreme slowness of the European Public Prosecutor's Office in investigating the purchase of COVID vaccines or the Qatar scandal;

Wording as published by the EP, in English. PE772.532

← Back to Main Vote
Status and procedure

Outcome as recorded by the European Parliament.

Vote held on
Latest recorded step
Official Journal · (401 days ago)
Next scheduled step
No further step is scheduled in the source.
Publication in the Official Journal recorded

Procedure timeline

2024/2019(DEC) · DEC

Recorded procedure activities. These do not establish whether a law has entered into force.

  1. Recorded: Referral37 days until the next step
  2. Recorded: Committee stage181 days until the next step
  3. Recorded: Plenary14 days until the next step
  4. Recorded: Other activity154 days until the next step
  5. Latest recorded: Official Journal
Recorded activities (46)
  1. Referral to committee
  2. Committee opinion tabled
  3. Committee opinion tabled
  4. Committee opinion tabled
  5. Committee opinion tabled
  6. Committee opinion tabled
  7. Committee opinion tabled
  8. Committee opinion tabled
  9. Committee opinion tabled
  10. Committee opinion tabled
  11. Committee report tabled
  12. Committee opinion adopted
  13. Committee opinion adopted
  14. Committee opinion adopted
  15. Committee opinion adopted
  16. Committee opinion adopted
  17. Committee opinion adopted
  18. Committee opinion adopted
  19. Committee opinion adopted
  20. Committee opinion adopted
  21. Committee opinion adopted
  22. Committee amendments tabled
  23. Committee amendments tabled
  24. Committee report adopted
  25. Tabling for plenary
  26. Tabling for plenary
  27. Tabling for plenary
  28. Tabling for plenary
  29. Tabling for plenary
  30. Tabling for plenary
  31. Tabling for plenary
  32. Tabling for plenary
  33. Tabling for plenary
  34. Tabling for plenary
  35. Tabling for plenary
  36. Tabling for plenary
  37. Tabling for plenary
  38. Tabling for plenary
  39. Tabling for plenary
  40. Tabling for plenary
  41. Tabling for plenary
  42. Plenary debate
  43. Other recorded activity
  44. Plenary vote
  45. Plenary vote results
  46. Publication in the Official Journal
Scheduled activities (not confirmation of completion)
  1. Plenary debate
  2. Plenary vote

Procedure file (OEIL) · European Parliament data
Retrieved:

Sources

Data: EP Open Data API

What is this about?

  • Discharge of the Commission for 2023 budget execution.
  • Court of Auditors confirms compliance with rules.
  • Publication in EU Official Journal required.
Source: AI Summary with Mistral

Vote by political group

How the political groups voted

Members

Showing 10 of 719

Vote Position
NameCountryGroupVote Position
FrancePfE
For
SpainPfE
For
GermanyNI
For
CzechiaNI
For
FrancePfE
For
CzechiaPfE
For
PolandECR
For
AustriaPfE
For
FranceEPP
For
PolandECR
For
Show more
Follow us on Instagram@checksomevotes@checksomevotes_en