Vote in the European Parliament

Extending the list of EU crimes to hate speech and hate crime

Maite Pagazaurtundúa - § 10 - Am 11
Date: 18.01.2024·Reference: A9-0377/2023
Rapporteur: Maite Pagazaurtundúa

Overall Result

Rejected
  • 117 For
  • 415 Against
  • 10 Abstention
  • 163 Did not vote
Amendment— You are viewing a sub-vote (amendment) of the main vote.Amendment 11 · Tabled by IDView amendment at the EP ↗
Amendment wording

Tabled by Patricia Chagnon, Harald Vilimsky, Nicolaus Fest, Jaak Madison

10. Recalls that freedom of Removed: expression, Added: expression is a foundational value of democratic societies and should not be Removed: unjustifiably restricted; further recalls that any legislation on hate speech and hate crime should be grounded in the principles of necessity and proportionality; underlines that freedom of expression must be exercised within the law and in line with Article 11 of the Charter and should not be exploited as a shield for Added: exploited to commit hate speech and hate crimes; Added: stresses, however, that the lack of a precise and objective definition of ‘hate speech’ could lead to disproportionate and unjustified restrictions; stresses that hate speech is a highly subjective notion and could therefore be exploited to limit freedom of expression, which is fundamental to our democracies;

Wording as published by the EP, in English. PE756.671

← Back to Main Vote
Status and procedure

Outcome as recorded by the European Parliament.

Vote held on
Latest recorded step
Plenary · (1081 days ago)
Next scheduled step
No further step is scheduled in the source.

Procedure timeline

2023/2068(INI) · INI

Recorded procedure activities. These do not establish whether a law has entered into force.

  1. Recorded: Referral25 days until the next step
  2. Recorded: Committee stage176 days until the next step
  3. Latest recorded: Plenary1081 days since this step began
Recorded activities (9)
  1. Referral to committee
  2. Committee opinion tabled
  3. Committee report tabled
  4. Committee opinion adopted
  5. Committee report adopted
  6. Tabling for plenary
  7. Plenary debate
  8. Plenary vote
  9. Plenary vote results
Scheduled activities (not confirmation of completion)
  1. Plenary debate
  2. Plenary vote

Procedure file (OEIL) · European Parliament data
Retrieved:

Sources

Data: EP Open Data API

Vote by political group

How the political groups voted

Members

Showing 10 of 705

Vote Position
NameCountryGroupVote Position
GermanyNI
For
SwedenNI
For
PolandNI
For
HungaryNI
For
FranceNI
For
NetherlandsNI
For
ItalyNI
For
ItalyNI
For
GermanyNI
For
AustriaPfE
For
Show more
Follow us on Instagram@checksomevotes@checksomevotes_en